| Name - School | 2024 | 2025 | Improvement |
| Maeve Going - Sacred Heart Academy | 12:34.71 | 9:44.93 | 2:49.78 |
| Addison Cyr - Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake | 13:18.72 | 10:51.01 | 2:27.71 |
| Kiera MacIntosh - Scotia-Glenville | 12:45.40 | 10:35.57 | 2:09.83 |
| Teagan Davis - Guilderland | 12:43.98 | 10:39.04 | 2:04.94 |
| Courtney Krawiecki - Shenendehowa | 12:01.22 | 10:14.43 | 1:46.79 |
| Hannah Delaney - Nyack | 12:41.00 | 10:55.90 | 1:45.10 |
| Melisa Davila - Susan E. Wagner | 12:38.97 | 11:01.49 | 1:37.48 |
| Tatiyana Fosu - Thomas R. Proctor | 13:49.04 | 12:17.88 | 1:31.16 |
| Phoebe Roth - Packer Collegiate | 13:27.04 | 11:59.51 | 1:27.53 |
| Mae O'Reilly - Eastchester | 12:33.66 | 11:07.88 | 1:25.78 |
| Mae Miller - Averill Park | 12:54.13 | 11:30.17 | 1:23.96 |
| Stella Cutaia - Pittsford-Mendon | 13:33.45 | 12:11.08 | 1:22.37 |
| Kadence Williams - Central Square | 11:55.65 | 10:34.30 | 1:21.35 |
| Jordan Citron - West End Secondary School | 13:21.10 | 12:00.30 | 1:20.80 |
| Emalyn Zeller - Oyster Bay | 11:54.70 | 10:42.36 | 1:12.34 |
| Carolina Cagna - Bethpage | 12:27.20 | 11:16.47 | 1:10.73 |
| Saughnessy Trevor - Rush Henrietta Sperry |