| Name | 2025 | 2024 | Difference |
| Kenneth Wolf - Chaminade | 5:01.55 | 6:01.01 | -59.46 |
| Lengsfield Lucas - Columbia Prep | 5:48.62 | 6:47.42 | -58.8 |
| Rohan Patel - John Jay - Cross River | 4:58.95 | 5:57.22 | -58.27 |
| Krish Modi - West Half Hollow Hills | 5:15.82 | 6:12.87 | -57.05 |
| Orfeo Trottereau - Lycee Francais De New York (LFNY) | 5:47.36 | 6:41.77 | -54.41 |
| Abukar Abubeker - Institute of Technology | 5:38.12 | 6:30.30 | -52.18 |
| Zach Paggi - Kellenberg Memorial | 4:28.95 | 5:21.00 | -52.05 |
| Philip Botlero - William C. Bryant | 6:18.10 | 7:10.10 | -52 |
| Sergi Dura - McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:51.10 | 6:41.18 | -50.08 |
| Raylucas Galan - North Babylon | 4:51.20 | 5:41.21 | -50.01 |
| Elijah Hernandez - Bronx HS Of Science | 4:46.43 | 5:36.17 | -49.74 |
| Tarun Patel - John Jay - Cross River | 5:10.74 | 6:00.32 | -49.58 |
| Jacob Miller - Columbia (Sec 2) | 5:28.98 | 6:18.31 | -49.33 |
| Fouad Sakr - Ellenville | 5:38.06 | 6:24.22 | -46.16 |
| Theodore Schalk - Manhattan Center for Scie | 5:13.67 | 5:59.81 | -46.14 |
| Idan Nutkevitz - HS For Math, Science and | 6:11.40 | 6:57.28 | -45.88 |
| Michael Gornstein - Kellenberg Memorial | 5:59.99 | 6:45.81 | -45.82 |
| John Deer - Bethlehem Central | 5:10.24 | 5:... |