Top 2023 Returning Runners by Last Year's TR Rating | Name | Grade | Section | Team | Season TR |
| Roan Kelly | 12 | 06-D | Randolph | 179 |
| Connor Domoy | 12 | 05-D | Oakfield-Alabama | 177 |
| Collin Stafford | 12 | 03-D | South Lewis | 177 |
| Van Furman | 11 | 09-D | Tri-Valley | 172 |
| Jude Rischpater | 12 | 05-D | Bloomfield-Naples | 169 |
| Anthony Zazzaro | 11 | 02-D | Stillwater | 165 |
| Conner Zehr | 12 | 03-D | Beaver River | 163 |
| Ethan Verbosky | 10 | 06-D | Maple Grove | 159 |
| Craig Costa | 12 | 09-D | Tri-Valley | 159 |
| Logan Clark | 11 | 05-D | Oakfield-Alabama | 157 |
| Carter Stevens | 12 | 03-D | Cooperstown | 156 |
| Sam DeJordy | 12 | 07-D | Seton Catholic | 156 |
| Lincoln McGrath | 12 | 05-D | Byron-Bergen | 155 |
| Aidan Fay | 11 | 07-D | Lake Placid | 154 |
| Jaydan Ruble | 11 | 06-D | Wilson | 154 |
| Gabe Kalisz | 12 | 02-D | Berlin | 153 |
| Cody Kent | 11 | 06-D | Frewsburg | 153 |
| Johnathan Garrison | 12 | 04-D | Candor | 151 |
| Salim Ford | 12 | 05-D | Arkport | 150 |
| MacCoy Maciejko | 11 | 03-D | South Lewis | 150 |
| Garrett Beebe | 12 | 07-D | Ticonderoga | 150 |
